Best Restaurants in Islamorada

The beautiful island of Islamorada in the Florida Keys is a vacation spot like no other. It is truly paradise. After a day of fishing, water activities and laying in the sun at the beach you’re going to want a delicious meal. We have you covered! 

We chose our favorite restaurants below in Islamorada based on criteria like reviews, menus and overall ambiance. Each one has something special to offer and is a guaranteed good time and delicious meal.

Congrats to all our winners!

Check out these awesome vacation rentals in Islamorada

Must-Try Restaurants in Islamorada, Florida

Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill 

Hog Heaven has more than one persona – by day it is a laid back sports bar with delicious seafood and inhouse smoked BBQ and by night it is a club with a DJ and all night party. They also have a private beach you can explore! 

Islamorada Fish Company 

Fish Company has ocean views, beautiful sunsets, fresh seafood and a huge saltwater fish tank in three of the locations. This restaurant is great for families or anyone looking for a great meal with a view.

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar 

Waterfront dining for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Lorelei has breathtaking views and live sunset entertainment. They also claim to have some of the best seafood in the Keys. And we think they are right! 

Italian Food Company

This cool spot on the island offers amazing authentic Italian cooking. The classic dishes are handmade with ingredients imported from Italy. It doesn’t get better than that!

Green Turtle Inn

Green Turtle Inn is an iconic landmark restaurant in Islamorada and has been around since 1947. This spot has lots of history, great service and a perfect casual vibe. They are open for breakfast, lunch and dinner with an awesome menu of Keys classics and Southern staples.

Lazy Days

Lazy Days is oceanfront dining to perfection! They offer some of the freshest seafood, steaks and pastas. If you catch something while fishing – they will also cook that for you! How cool? Their award-winning dishes and fantastic views make this a go-to destination while in the Keys.

Marker 88

Looking for a great summer happy hour spot? Look no further! Marker 88 is a local favorite and has been serving up fantastic dishes and drinks since 1967. The views, food and drinks are all top notch. Make sure to check out The 88 Boutique as well for a souvenir!

Island Grill

Island Grill is a perfect stop for a great meal or if you have an event coming up their banquet space is top of the line. The menu has locally sourced seafood as well as regional specialties.

Hungry Tarpon

This beautiful restaurant has gorgeous views and incredible food. It is a true Keys experience dining here. Enjoy a tropical atmosphere, scenic views, great food and perfectly crafted drinks. They will even cook your catch! This staple restaurant is a must-visit on your next trip!