Sanibel Island Rentals by Owner

(9 rentals)
booking message booking message
Sanibel Island House
4 BR | 3 BA | Sleeps 10 | Quick View
Sleeps 10, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
1 review

Distance to beach: 1 miles to Sanibel Beachs

$467

avg/night

$467
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Escape to the beauty of Sanibel Island with a stay at our exquisite 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom ranch-style home. With 2,100 sq ft of living space, this modern and meticulously designed property offers a perfect blend of comfort and luxury.Key Features:Spacious 4 bedrooms: Master bedroom with a king ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island House

Featured review

"Best Location and Wonderful Retreat!"

We typically stay in Fort Myers Beach but our favorite spot was washed away by the storm. We were so excited to find out Nate has a new property on Sanibel. The location is so desirable, island living at ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island House
3 BR | 2 BA | Sleeps 6 | Quick View
Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms

$133

avg/night

$133
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Relaxing home in quiet neighborhood. Pool ( caged). 3 bedrooms. 2 bath stilt home on Sanibel's west end. Casual beach decor. Spacious open floor plan with vaulted ceilings. Walk or ride your bike to Bowmans Beach. Close to Ding Darling Nature Preserve, CROW, Blind Pass and Turner Beaches and recreation ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island House

Show less

Sanibel Island Condo
2 BR | 2 BA | Sleeps 5 | Quick View
Sleeps 5, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
2 reviews

Distance to beach: 50 feet to Pointe Santo Beach

$406

avg/night

$406
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Hot tub
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

We are excited to welcome renters back on February 1, 2025. We appreciate your patience as we continue to rebuild our beloved Pointe Santo. Our beach and tennis/pickleball courts are open. The pool is slated to open in April barring any unforeseen delays. Please note there may be some noise as ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island Condo

Featured review

"Great to Be Home: My Florida Home Away From Home"

Great to be back to the place I’ve been coming for some 25 years, I tell people it is one of the last great places. This condo gives you a very homey feel with exceptional views, so even on the few bad ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island House
4 BR | 2.5 BA | Sleeps 10 | Quick View
Sleeps 10, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms
2 reviews

Distance to beach: 1 miles to Private Beach

$571

avg/night

$571
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Pet friendly
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Brand New post-Hurricane Ian Ranked Top 25 Beach in the WorldThis fabulous 4 bedroom private estate is on Sanibel's premier east end. No detail has been overlooked in this coastal modern, pet-friendly, waterfront home.This coastal modern home is inviting and comfortable, from its stylish ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island House

Featured review

"Don't miss the beautiful sunsets at the Coral Sea!"

We just returned home from an amazing month at the Coral Sea in Sanibel – truly a special home to make great memories. And the sunsets are beautiful! Julie and Larry were wonderful to work with before ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island Condo
2 BR | 2 BA | Sleeps 4 | Quick View
Sleeps 4, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
6 reviews

Distance to beach: 150 yards to Loggerhead Cay is on the beach

$247

avg/night

$247
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Oceanfront
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Note: All photos are Pre-Ian. Loggerhead Cay is a top rated complex, on the beach, with quiet surroundings. First floor convenience...walk out from the Lanai to the pool and beach. Great for a couple, or fits four persons. 2 Bedrooms, each with it's private bathroom. Private bedrooms. Premium ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island Condo

Featured review

"Beautiful condo"

We had a wonderful experience from the start to the end. The unto is beautiful, very comfortable, and well stocked with everything you need. The units location is great and the view was perfect. The property ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island Townhome
4 BR | 3 BA | Sleeps 10 | Quick View
Sleeps 10, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
6 reviews

Distance to beach: 1000 feet to Sanibel Bay

$307

avg/night

$307
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Spacious well-equipped property, a five-minute stroll to the Bay. on Sanibel Island's east coast. Lots of room as the property hosts 2 bedrooms & 2 baths on the main floor and 2 bedrooms, and 1 full bath upstairs for visiting family & friends. It is a townhouse with a shared heated swimming ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island Townhome

Featured review

"Beautiful Sanibel"

This townhouse comes with it all!! We especially loved the bikes that Mary provides and ALL the beach gear she provides as well. The location was perfect and the bay was only about 5 minutes from the house. ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island Condo
2 BR | 2 BA | Sleeps 6 | Quick View
Sleeps 6, 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
1 review

$444

avg/night

$444
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Beachfront
  • Oceanfront
  • Pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Condo, 2 Bedrooms + Den, 2 Baths, (Sleeps 6) Located on Sanibel Island, our unit at the Sanddollar is a spacious 1,660 sq. ft. Luxuriously furnished gulf front condominium. Two bedrooms plus den, 2 full bathrooms. Our unit has a 26' screened-in porch overlooking the ocean. Exceptional view of the ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island Condo

Featured review

"Terrific!"

We are at the end of our stay in Sanibel and couldn’t be more happy with the accommodations. The condo was stocked with everything we needed in the kitchen, towels and linens, paper products, plus beach ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island House
3 BR | 2.5 BA | Sleeps 6 | Quick View
Sleeps 6, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms
7 reviews

Distance to beach: 2 miles to Bowman Beach

$128

avg/night

$128
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Pet friendly
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Pristine, lovely home in quiet subdivision, 400 yards from the Gulf of Mexico and the spectacular beaches on Sanibel Island’s west end. Access to bike paths, and a complimentary community boat ramp two homes away, which provides convenience for boating and kayaking. Lush tropical vegetation provides ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island House

Featured review

"Sanibel Dreaming"

I had a wonderful time in Sanibel, much of this due to Heidi's home on Pine ave. The previous reviewer said it all: the house is perfectly outfitted for a great vacation. The home is light-filled, comfy, ...

See all reviews

Show less

Sanibel Island House
4 BR | 4 BA | Sleeps 8 | Quick View
Sleeps 8, 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms
2 reviews

Distance to beach: 1 miles to Multiple within 1-2 miles

$244

avg/night

$244
avg per night
View Details

Key Amenities

  • Air conditioning
  • Hot tub
  • Private pool
  • Rentals by owner
  • WiFi

About this property

Sand Castle On The Lake(All new interior decorating on the first floor since Hurricane Ian including an update to the pool.)Lakefront 4 BR, 4 full Bath Sanibel Home. Private Pool. Central Island Location.As soon as you pull up to our home, you'll know you're someplace special. Our ...

View all property information

Property Type

Sanibel Island House

Featured review

"Great house"

The view out of our back was phenomenal. We enjoyed incredible viewing of wildlife on the lake, our nice looking pool and a private feel. Though the home is in a neighborhood, you don’t feel close to ...

See all reviews

Show less

Map
Expand map Close map
Sanibel Island Vacation Rentals